Having lube issues

Hello. I’ve been playing with aneros for 5 years now. Never had a dry prostate orgasm. I think the lube is an issue for me. I have been using Walmart equate water lube but it dries way too quick. I’ve tried some Amazon water lube but that also dries quick.

Tried Coconut oil and put it in an injector and squeezed out like 4 tubes worth and also coated the toy. It still felt very dry inside the hole. Afterwards I was having wet farms and had to go to the bathroom everything I felt it coming. That lasted for 2 days 🤕

I just don’t know what else to try. Some of the toys I have are silicon so no silicon lube.

I’m at the end of my rope here as I think the lube problem is dampening my experiance